Guesthouse Tomoshibi vs Hotel Iidaya

Same City · Matsumoto Distance: 28.9km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Guesthouse Tomoshibi

8.1 84
Matsumoto
View Details →

Hotel Iidaya

★★★ 3-Star
8.3 2,789
Matsumoto
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Guesthouse Tomo... Hotel Iidaya
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking
라쿠텐트래블 Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Guesthouse Tomo... Hotel Iidaya
Agoda
8.2 (357)
8.1 (3,455)
Booking.com
8.2 (235)
7.6 (1,550)
Expedia
7.8 (20)
-
Trip.com
7.9 (18)
8.3 (82)
Overall Average
8.1 (630)
8.3 (5,087)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Guesthouse Tomoshibi Hotel Iidaya
Strengths Strengths
+ 24-hour onsen praised as hot and skin-smoothing across multiple sites + Overwhelming reviews praise the location right in front of the station, 1-2 min walk to train, bus, convenience stores
+ Owners' kindness and tasty affordable sukiyaki meals frequently mentioned + Repeated mentions of staff's kindness, thoughtful service like deodorizing smoking rooms
+ Walk to Kamikochi bus terminal in 5 mins, convenient for hikers + Consistent praise for room cleanliness and basic amenities
+ Nature setting with river sounds and views enjoyed in reviews + Convenient access to nearby sights and restaurants
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Paraffin heater smell and gas fumes complained in reviews - Multiple reviews note small rooms with dated feel, firm beds and pillows
- Dated facilities and shared showers seen as inconvenient - Smoking room odors not fully removed, lack of non-smoking rooms mentioned
- Thin walls let hallway footsteps be heard - Some complaints about window noise, AC control issues, minor cleaning oversights

Recommended For

Kamikochi hikers Couples Budget travelers Solo travelers

Recommended For

Solo travelers Couples Business travelers

Guest Reviews

Guesthouse Tomoshibi

Trip.com 10 Couple

Great for Kamikochi, sukiyaki dinner and onsen top-notch

Trip.com 10 Couple

Peaceful ryokan, affordable food, 24h onsen, kind host

Booking.com 3.6 Solo

Friendly staff free food, amazing onsen, near bus

Old heater oil smell

Agoda 10 Solo

Best for Kamikochi, kind host, good price

Expedia 10 Group

Excellent hospitality and dinner, perfect early Kamikochi start

Hotel Iidaya

Booking.com 7.6 Solo

Perfect station location, friendly staff, clean room

Agoda 8.4 Solo traveler

Early check-in help, courteous staff, perfect location

Facilities dated

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Convenient near station, many nearby amenities for exploring

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Spacious room, close to station, good staff response

Firm mattress

Trip.com 9.2 Couple

Excellent location, enthusiastic staff, walk to bus and castle

Location Comparison

Distance: 28.9km

Guesthouse Tomoshibi View Details → Hotel Iidaya View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.