The Edgewater Hotel vs The Dylin

Same City · Madison Distance: 0.8km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

The Edgewater Hotel

★★★★ 4-Star
9.2 215
Madison
View Details →

The Dylin

★★★ 3-Star
9.1 181
Madison
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site The Edgewater H... The Dylin
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site The Edgewater H... The Dylin
Agoda
9.2 (215)
9.1 (181)
Booking.com
8.8 (155)
8.9 (144)
Expedia
9.2 (1,000)
9.4 (134)
Trip.com
9.1 (102)
9.0 (55)
Overall Average
9.2 (1,472)
9.1 (514)

Strengths & Weaknesses

The Edgewater Hotel The Dylin
Strengths Strengths
+ Lake views impress across multiple sites + Rooms are clean and modern design praised in many reviews
+ Rooms are spacious, clean, with comfy beds often noted + Full kitchen and washer/dryer make it convenient for long stays, repeatedly mentioned
+ Friendly staff and convenient shuttle mentioned commonly + Quiet neighborhood but close to Capitol and restaurants, location praised often
+ On-site restaurant food and bar praised frequently + Digital check-in and responsive staff highlighted in reviews
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Some rooms have carpet stains or cleanliness issues - Some rooms have AC noise mentioned in reviews
- Tub drainage or low water pressure noted in reviews - Garage entrance can be confusing, need to be careful per reviews
- Extra fees for parking or room service seen as pricey

Recommended For

Couples Families Leisure travelers

Recommended For

Business travelers Couples Long-stay guests

Guest Reviews

The Edgewater Hotel

Agoda 10 Couple

Beautiful lake view, friendly staff, convenient location

Trip.com 10 Couple

Perfect anniversary, welcome treat and Christmas decor great

Expedia 10 Couple

Top lake view and spa, spacious luxury rooms

Booking.com 4.0 Solo

Great location and staff, charming building

Fried food smell in lobby

Trip.com 6 Other

Great staff and location

2nd floor felt like dark basement, poor water pressure

The Dylin

Expedia 10.0 Solo

Clean spacious room with washer dryer full kitchen. Great neighborhood near downtown.

Booking.com 4.0 Couple

Clean spacious room. Sink issue fixed immediately with upgrade, great service.

Booking.com 4.0 Solo

Clean new with all amenities. Easy underground parking.

Careful entering garage

Trip.com 10.0 Other

Easy check-in super clean room. Close to Sylvee bars restaurants lake.

Agoda 9.0 Business

Almost perfect, want to come back.

Location Comparison

Distance: 0.8km

The Edgewater Hotel View Details → The Dylin View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.