Shinanoki Ichinoyu vs Hakone Hoshi no Akari

Same City · Hakone Distance: 2.9km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Shinanoki Ichinoyu

★★★ 3-Star
8.4 698
Hakone
View Details →

Hakone Hoshi no Akari

★★★ 3-Star
8.6 155
Hakone
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Shinanoki Ichinoyu Hakone Hoshi no...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking
라쿠텐트래블 Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Shinanoki Ichinoyu Hakone Hoshi no...
Agoda
8.7 (1,885)
8.9 (737)
Expedia
-
9.0
Trip.com
9.2 (170)
-
Overall Average
8.4 (2,055)
8.6 (737)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Shinanoki Ichinoyu Hakone Hoshi no Akari
Strengths Strengths
+ Private open-air baths are spacious, clean, and perfectly heated, per many reviews + Many reviews praise stargazing and views from the room's outdoor onsen
+ Traditional ryokan dinners and breakfasts are delicious and hearty, repeatedly noted + Staff's kind and attentive service repeatedly praised
+ Staff's kind and attentive service is mentioned across reviews + Dinner and breakfast delicious with fresh ingredients and generous portions
+ Rooms are spacious, clean, and comfortable with good bedding, commonly praised + Small size means no crowds, relaxed stay
+ 24-hour outdoor onsen access is convenient
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Remote location requires about an hour by bus, a common complaint - Outdoor onsen faces golf course, privacy concerns
- Inconvenient and cold to move to annex buildings in rain - Facilities and rooms feel dated and worn
- Some note chlorine smell in onsen water or overly salty meals - No elevator, stairs inconvenient

Recommended For

Couples Solo travelers Families

Recommended For

Couples Pairs Onsen lovers

Guest Reviews

Shinanoki Ichinoyu

Agoda 10.0 Solo traveler

Private onsen spacious and clean, best meals, great value

Agoda 8.0 Couple

Private onsen relaxing, room spacious, meals tasty

Bus one hour from main station

Trip.com 9.0 Friends

Good meals, friendly staff, enjoyed private onsen

Trip.com 10.0 Couple

Great private onsen facilities, delicious breakfast pudding

Convenience store a bit far

Agoda 9.6 Couple

Excellent traditional ryokan experience, very clean

Hakone Hoshi no Akari

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Super kind staff, great food, convenient luggage service

Agoda 9.2 Couple

First stargazing onsen, delicious meals, relaxing bird sounds

Public bath not hot spring

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Great room onsen view, impressive staff and food

Balcony shower privacy issue

Agoda 9.6 Couple

Overwhelming views, refillable rice delicious, private dining

Slipper leaks, vending drinks not cold

Location Comparison

Distance: 2.9km

Shinanoki Ichinoyu View Details → Hakone Hoshi no Akari View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.