Shima Yamaguchikan vs Shima Tamura Ryokan

Same City · Nakanojō Distance: 1.2km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Shima Yamaguchikan

★★★ 3-Star
8.5 149
Nakanojō
View Details →

Shima Tamura Ryokan

★★★★ 4-Star
8.6 126
Nakanojō
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Shima Yamaguchikan Shima Tamura Ry...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking
라쿠텐트래블 Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Shima Yamaguchikan Shima Tamura Ry...
Agoda
8.3 (266)
8.3 (234)
Trip.com
9.0 (34)
7.8 (18)
Overall Average
8.5 (300)
8.6 (252)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Shima Yamaguchikan Shima Tamura Ryokan
Strengths Strengths
+ Riverside open-air baths are clean and great for skin, per many reviews + Many reviews praise the variety of onsens with different temperatures and views
+ Friendly staff and landlady's fun paper puppet show + Kaiseki dinners and breakfasts are tasty and satisfying, repeatedly mentioned
+ Dinners are diverse and filling, repeatedly praised + Staff are kind and attentive across multiple reviews
+ Rooms are quiet, comfortable with river views + Guests enjoy the historic building atmosphere and natural mountain setting
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Rural location makes access a bit tricky by car, some say - Some complaints about unclean areas or odors due to the old building
- Building looks dated in some mentions - Steep slope makes luggage transport inconvenient, repeatedly noted
- Reviews point out poor bathroom or changing room hygiene

Recommended For

Couples Friends Families

Recommended For

Couples Onsen lovers Adult travelers

Guest Reviews

Shima Yamaguchikan

Trip.com 10 Couple

Classic cozy vibe, helpful staff, great onsen

Trip.com 10 Friends

Quiet relaxing location, tasty dinner, clean river-view open bath

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Best onsen esp river-view outdoor, friendly staff, nearby sushi

Agoda 8.8 Couple

Soft water smooths skin, comfy bedding, late check-in ok

Agoda 10 Couple

Human service feels comfy, thorough cleaning, well-kept baths

Shima Tamura Ryokan

Trip.com 10 Couple

Great variety of onsens and friendly staff

Trip.com 8.5 Family

Varied indoor/outdoor onsens and good food quality

Trip.com 10 Solo

Excellent outdoor onsen, great traditional vibe

Agoda 10 Couple

Perfect relaxation with waterfall and mountain views

Agoda 9.6 Couple

7 onsens with unique charms, spacious clean rooms

Location Comparison

Distance: 1.2km

Shima Yamaguchikan View Details → Shima Tamura Ryokan View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.