Hotel New Mogamiya vs Guesthouse Mintaro Hut

Same City · Yamagata Distance: 0.9km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Hotel New Mogamiya

★ 1-Star
7.4 621
Yamagata
View Details →

Guesthouse Mintaro Hut

★ 1-Star
9.1 152
Yamagata
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Hotel New Mogamiya Guesthouse Mint...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking
라쿠텐트래블 Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Hotel New Mogamiya Guesthouse Mint...
Agoda
7.3 (742)
9.1 (523)
Booking.com
6.8 (267)
9.2 (350)
Trip.com
8.0 (35)
-
Overall Average
7.4 (1,044)
9.1 (873)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Hotel New Mogamiya Guesthouse Mintaro Hut
Strengths Strengths
+ Many reviews praise the 3-5 minute walk to Yamagata Station for easy access + Host is extremely friendly and welcoming, repeatedly mentioned
+ Spacious rooms and comfortable beds mentioned repeatedly + Communal dinners and kitchen use are delicious and fun
+ Tasty breakfast with good value across sites + Rooms are clean, spacious, and feel homey
+ Flexible luggage storage before/after check-in noted in reviews + Great atmosphere for mingling with other travelers
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Dated facilities with dusty vents, moldy fridge smells, smoke odors repeated in complaints - Poor soundproofing with noise complaints
- Slow or indifferent staff, often no response to bell - Beds are firm, some find them uncomfortable
- Unstable hot water and no bidet noted

Recommended For

Solo travelers Business travelers Zao Onsen visitors

Recommended For

Solo travelers Couples Social travelers

Guest Reviews

Hotel New Mogamiya

Agoda 7.6 Solo

Under 5 min to station, spacious room comfy bed

Dusty vent and unstable shower temp

Agoda 9.6 Solo

Near bus stop smooth checkout friendly staff

Trip.com 10 Solo

2-3 min to station clean spacious well-maintained

Trip.com 10 Solo

Good soundproofing delicious breakfast high value

Booking.com 4.0 Individual

Near station good price clean

No bidet dated feel

Guesthouse Mintaro Hut

Booking.com 4.0

Cozy welcoming vibe, big room, great shared dinners

Best for those who like sharing

Booking.com 4.0

Friendly clean guesthouse, amazing dinner

Agoda 9.6 Solo traveler

Warm host and guests, fun communal dinner

Agoda 10.0 Solo traveler

Friendly staff, clean room, convenient self breakfast

Location Comparison

Distance: 0.9km

Hotel New Mogamiya View Details → Guesthouse Mintaro Hut View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.