Atlantic Motor Inn vs JG Time Hotel by JGSTAY Times Square

Same City · New York Distance: 10.4km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Atlantic Motor Inn

★★ 2-Star
7.0 11
New York
View Details →

JG Time Hotel by JGSTAY Times Square

★★ 2-Star
8.6 62
New York
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Atlantic Motor Inn JG Time Hotel b...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Atlantic Motor Inn JG Time Hotel b...
Agoda
7.2 (15)
8.4 (701)
Booking.com
5.0 (192)
7.5 (66)
Expedia
-
8.0 (384)
Trip.com
5.1 (1)
7.3 (1)
Overall Average
7.0 (208)
8.6 (1,152)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Atlantic Motor Inn JG Time Hotel by JGSTAY Times Square
Strengths Strengths
+ Convenient location near restaurants and train stations mentioned often + Location is top-notch, just a short walk to Times Square and Broadway shows, per many reviews
+ Free parking repeatedly praised as a big plus + Rooms are clean with comfortable beds, repeated across sites
+ Staff friendly and helpful with check-in and issues + Friendly staff who help with luggage get frequent praise
+ Quiet for the area with good shower pressure
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Train noise heard all night in multiple reviews - Rooms are extremely small, hard to fit luggage, common complaint
- Rooms rundown with cleanliness issues (odors, stains, bed bugs) repeated - No elevator makes stairs tough, especially higher floors
- Frequent mentions of broken AC, outlets, doors - Neighbor noise or shower leaks noted in some reviews

Recommended For

Budget travelers Drivers Short stayers

Recommended For

Couples Solo travelers Show-goers

Guest Reviews

Atlantic Motor Inn

Agoda 9.6 Business traveler

Friendly staff, free parking good for short stay

Agoda 2.0 Solo traveler

Bed bugs

Trip.com 10.0 Solo traveler

Quick check-in, easy come and go

Booking.com 2.4 Individual

Near train, free parking

Train noise, AC/remote broken

Booking.com 1.6 Individual

Near restaurants

Door wouldn't open, outlets not working

JG Time Hotel by JGSTAY Times Square

Expedia 10.0 Couple

Close to Times Square, perfect AC for shows

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Tiny but spotless, prime location with great eats nearby

Agoda 8.4 Couple

Fine for NYC where you don't linger in room

No elevator

Booking.com 4.0 Solo traveler

Perfect location, cleanliness, cozy vibe

Expedia 8.0 Solo traveler

Super clean and quiet, comfy bed

Thin walls let in noise

Location Comparison

Distance: 10.4km

Atlantic Motor Inn View Details → JG Time Hotel by JGSTAY Times Square View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.