Carlton Lygon Lodge vs Punthill Apartment Hotel - Flinders Lane

Same City · Melbourne Distance: 1.7km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Carlton Lygon Lodge

★★★ 3-Star
8.5 356
Melbourne
View Details →

Punthill Apartment Hotel - Flinders Lane

★★★★ 4-Star
8.5 420
Melbourne
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Carlton Lygon L... Punthill Apartm...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Carlton Lygon L... Punthill Apartm...
Agoda
8.3 (405)
8.4 (2,429)
Booking.com
-
7.7 (1,587)
Expedia
8.4 (1,000)
8.6 (1,474)
Overall Average
8.5 (1,405)
8.5 (5,490)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Carlton Lygon Lodge Punthill Apartment Hotel - Flinders Lane
Strengths Strengths
+ Excellent location surrounded by numerous restaurants and cafes with easy access to public transport + Centrally located in Melbourne CBD, offering easy access to major attractions and trams
+ Consistently clean rooms and friendly, attentive staff + Spacious rooms compared to standard hotels, equipped with functional kitchen facilities
+ Great value for money, offering spacious rooms with kitchenettes and balconies + Friendly staff and efficient check-in process
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Potential for noise during the evening due to the surrounding dining area - Facilities are somewhat dated with signs of wear on furniture and bathrooms
- Some reports of low water pressure in bathrooms - Housekeeping and amenity replenishment services are limited during weekends or extended stays
- Potential for street noise due to the central location

Recommended For

Value-seeking travelers Foodies

Recommended For

Long-term guests Sightseers

Guest Reviews

Carlton Lygon Lodge

Expedia 10.0 Couple

Great position, clean rooms, and very friendly staff

Agoda 9.2 Solo traveler

Great price for a large room with a kitchen and balcony

Agoda 8.8 Family

Good access to the city and daily fresh towel service

A bit noisy at night due to the area

Punthill Apartment Hotel - Flinders Lane

Agoda 10.0 Solo traveler

Excellent location and good value. In-room coffee machine is a great touch.

Booking.com 7.2 Couple

Great location and fabulous staff.

Apartments are dated and could use a revamp.

Location Comparison

Distance: 1.7km

Carlton Lygon Lodge View Details → Punthill Apartment Hotel - Flinders Lane View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.