City Hotel Southern Cross vs Minn Nishi Kasai

Same City · Tokyo Distance: 14.8km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

City Hotel Southern Cross

★★★ 3-Star
6.7 595
Tokyo
View Details →

Minn Nishi Kasai

★★★ 3-Star
8.6 1,910
Tokyo
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site City Hotel Sout... Minn Nishi Kasai
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking
라쿠텐트래블 Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site City Hotel Sout... Minn Nishi Kasai
Agoda
6.7 (590)
8.6 (1,918)
Booking.com
5.9 (353)
8.6 (1,405)
Expedia
-
9.2 (466)
Trip.com
-
8.9 (155)
Overall Average
6.7 (943)
8.6 (3,944)

Strengths & Weaknesses

City Hotel Southern Cross Minn Nishi Kasai
Strengths Strengths
+ Many reviews praise the 2-minute walk to the station for easy Shinjuku access + Rooms are spacious and clean unlike typical Japanese hotels, per most reviews
+ Repeated praise for clean bathrooms and spacious showers + Nishi-Kasai Station 4-min walk, convenience stores/markets/restaurants next door for easy living
+ Staff friendliness and useful luggage storage mentioned often + Kitchen facilities and coin laundry useful for families/long stays
+ Convenience stores and restaurants nearby make daily life easy + Quiet and safe residential area praised consistently
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Repeated complaints about small, old rooms with humidity and smells - Unmanned check-in and QR/password confusion for first-timers
- Thin walls let in outside noise frequently mentioned - No staff late night, only remote support for issues
- English communication issues and key deposit system feel inconvenient - 30+ min subway to tourist centers

Recommended For

Solo travelers Couples Budget travelers

Recommended For

Families Budget travelers Disney visitors

Guest Reviews

City Hotel Southern Cross

Booking.com 6.0

Right next to station, easy to Shinjuku, clean facilities wide shower quiet

Small room staff no English

Booking.com 7.1

Nice bathroom good location

Agoda 7.2 Couple

Separate bath toilet clean friendly staff

Thin walls noise

Agoda 6.8 Solo

Near station convenience store bathtub nice

Agoda 8.0 Couple

Great location clean room kind staff

Minn Nishi Kasai

Trip.com 9.5 Family

Clean good location family of 4 stayed well

Expedia 10.0 Family

Spacious clean near station and stores

Agoda 10.0 Family with kids

Enough space for 4 laundry convenient and clean

Booking.com 4.0 Family

Next to station stores laundry good quiet

Pillows too hard

Trip.com 2.0 Couple

Clean location space value good

Door lock issue worst service

Location Comparison

Distance: 14.8km

City Hotel Southern Cross View Details → Minn Nishi Kasai View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.