Cockatoo Island - Accommodation vs Manly Beach Guesthouse

Same City · Sydney Distance: 12.0km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Cockatoo Island - Accommodation

★★★★ 4-Star
8.0 43
Sydney
View Details →

Manly Beach Guesthouse

★★★ 3-Star
7.3 266
Sydney
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Cockatoo Island... Manly Beach Gue...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Cockatoo Island... Manly Beach Gue...
Agoda
8.3 (100)
7.5 (726)
Booking.com
8.4 (146)
7.1 (424)
Trip.com
-
6.7 (6)
Overall Average
8.0 (246)
7.3 (1,156)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Cockatoo Island - Accommodation Manly Beach Guesthouse
Strengths Strengths
+ Stunning Sydney Harbour views and a private island atmosphere + Excellent location within walking distance to Manly Beach and local shops
+ Outdoor BBQ and play areas perfect for families + Well-equipped communal kitchen with plenty of utensils for cooking
+ A unique experience of camping in nature away from the city + Positive feedback on comfortable bedding and overall room cleanliness
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Confusion regarding bedding and cooking utensils based on booking terms - Inconvenience of shared bathrooms and inconsistent cleanliness
- Inconvenience due to early closing times of island facilities and cafes - Noise from other floors and outside due to building structure
- Reports of rubber smells in some tents or aging facilities - Feedback regarding missing basic room amenities like cups or coffee

Recommended For

Camping Enthusiasts Families

Recommended For

Solo travelers Budget-conscious travelers

Guest Reviews

Cockatoo Island - Accommodation

Agoda 10.0 Solo traveler

Tents were well-maintained and clean. Great spot to watch fireworks.

Agoda 4.8 Couple

Need to check if bedding is included. Kitchen facilities are limited.

Booking.com 3.6 Family

Great for exploring with kids and enjoying BBQ.

Cafe closes early, so bring your own food.

Manly Beach Guesthouse

Agoda 9.6 Family

Convenient location near beach and shops, clean bathroom with good water pressure.

Trip.com 10 Other

Manager is kind, safe atmosphere, and great beach access.

Booking.com 3.2 Other

Very clean and comfy bed. Fantastic location.

Trip.com 2 Other

Shared bathrooms are not clean and rooms smell like cigarettes.

Booking.com 2.8 Other

Location is fantastic.

Ground floor rooms suffer from kitchen noise and smells.

Location Comparison

Distance: 12.0km

Cockatoo Island - Accommodation View Details → Manly Beach Guesthouse View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.