Dom Pedro Garajau vs Valley View Hotel Encumeada

Same City · Madeira Island Distance: 20.0km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Dom Pedro Garajau

★★★ 3-Star
8.2 415
Madeira Island
View Details →

Valley View Hotel Encumeada

★★★ 3-Star
8.0 43
Madeira Island
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Dom Pedro Garajau Valley View Hot...
Agoda
Booking.com
Expedia
Trip.com

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Dom Pedro Garajau Valley View Hot...
Agoda
8.2 (420)
8.0 (49)
Booking.com
7.4 (2,891)
7.6 (348)
Expedia
7.4 (484)
-
Trip.com
-
7.7 (7)
Overall Average
8.2 (3,795)
8.0 (404)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Dom Pedro Garajau Valley View Hotel Encumeada
Strengths Strengths
+ Clean rooms and daily housekeeping repeatedly mentioned + Location right by hiking trails like PR17 is repeatedly mentioned
+ Bus stop right outside makes Funchal trips easy, per many reviews + Stunning mountain views are frequently praised
+ Breakfast variety and quality praised across sites + Staff are commonly described as friendly and helpful
+ Indoor/outdoor pools and gardens well-maintained, families love them + Rooms are spacious and clean according to reviews
+ Friendly, helpful staff noted on multiple sites + Buffet breakfast is decent in many reviews
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Dated hotel with old furniture and facilities, common complaint - Dated facilities and old rooms are common complaints
- Thin walls let in noise from adjacent rooms, many mentions - Heating shortages or no hot water in reviews
- No room WiFi, only lobby, frequently inconvenient - Noise (poor soundproofing, parties) and cleaning issues mentioned
- No on-site parking, street parking tough and paid

Recommended For

Families Couples Island explorers

Recommended For

Hikers Couples Solo travelers

Guest Reviews

Dom Pedro Garajau

Booking.com 7.4 Family

Clean with good pools and location

Noise and dated rooms

Expedia 8.0 Couple

Great staff and views

No WiFi or AC

Trip.com 8.5 Couple

Good location pools and breakfast

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Clean pools and breakfast great

Lobby WiFi only

Booking.com 7.4 Solo

Varied breakfast friendly staff

Hard parking few outlets

Valley View Hotel Encumeada

Trip.com 10 Couple

Front desk staff helpful 24/7, room comfortable

Trip.com 9 Couple

Service top-notch, amazing sights

Booking.com 8 Solo

Great hiking start, friendly staff

Restaurant cold

Agoda 10 Couple

Staff dried boots and welcomed us

Agoda 10 Group

Perfect for island drives, stunning nature

Location Comparison

Distance: 20.0km

Dom Pedro Garajau View Details → Valley View Hotel Encumeada View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.