Hilltop Hostel vs Extended Stay America Select Suites - Atlanta - Cumberland Mall

Same City · Atlanta Distance: 13.5km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Hilltop Hostel

★★★ 3-Star
6.8 3
Atlanta
View Details →

Extended Stay America Select Suites - Atlanta - Cumberland Mall

★★ 2-Star
7.8 1,618
Atlanta
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Hilltop Hostel Extended Stay A...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Hilltop Hostel Extended Stay A...
Agoda
6.8 (3)
7.8 (1,622)
Booking.com
5.7 (7)
-
Overall Average
6.8 (10)
7.8 (1,622)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Hilltop Hostel Extended Stay America Select Suites - Atlanta - Cumberland Mall
Strengths Strengths
+ Reviews repeatedly mention spacious and clean rooms and common areas + Many reviews praise the convenient location with mall and restaurants within walking distance
+ Wall art is impressive to some guests + Front desk staff are repeatedly noted as friendly and helpful
+ Staff friendliness is noted + Pet-friendly with up to 2 pets allowed and poop bags provided
+ Some guests say it's quiet and feels like home
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Guest noise and privacy invasions (curtains opened, no door locks) in multiple reviews - Multiple complaints about dirty floors, bathrooms, and moldy smells
- Poor cleaning and maintenance issues (wall collapse) repeated - Reviews often point out cockroaches, rusty microwaves, and outdated facilities
- Late-night manager entries and dramatic atmosphere complained about - AC not cooling well, cigarette smells, and noise mentioned in reviews

Recommended For

Budget short-term travelers

Recommended For

Budget travelers Pet owners Car-free travelers

Guest Reviews

Hilltop Hostel

Booking.com 4.0

Big comfortable room, nice staff

Booking.com 4.0

Clean spacious common areas good for staying out

Booking.com 0.4

Noise, privacy invasion, poor cleaning

Agoda 10.0 Business traveler

High satisfaction

Extended Stay America Select Suites - Atlanta - Cumberland Mall

Agoda 5.2 Couple

Cabinets and floor dirty, microwave rusted

Agoda 6.0 Couple

Walkable location, pet-friendly

Room dirty, smoke smell, AC not cooling

Agoda 3.6 Couple

Filthy with roaches, moldy smell, long wait

Agoda 8.0 Solo

Good location, cheap, good service

Agoda 7.2 Solo

Great location, friendly staff

Location Comparison

Distance: 13.5km

Hilltop Hostel View Details → Extended Stay America Select Suites - Atlanta - Cumberland Mall View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.