Holiday Inn Melbourne Bourke Street Mall By IHG vs Punthill Caroline Springs

Same City · Melbourne Distance: 20.9km

Overview

vs

Holiday Inn Melbourne Bourke Street Mall By IHG

★★★ 3-Star
9.4 84
Melbourne
View Details →

Punthill Caroline Springs

★★★★ 4-Star
8.7 38
Melbourne
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Holiday Inn Mel... Punthill Caroli...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Holiday Inn Mel... Punthill Caroli...
Agoda
9.2 (928)
8.6 (907)
Booking.com
9.2 (440)
8.5 (771)
Overall Average
9.4 (1,368)
8.7 (1,678)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Holiday Inn Melbourne Bourke Street Mall By IHG Punthill Caroline Springs
Strengths Strengths
+ Excellent central location with major shopping malls and tram stops right at the doorstep + Well-equipped kitchen facilities make it convenient for long-term stays
+ Overall cleanliness and modern interior due to the 2025 opening + Various restaurants located within the building make dining easy
+ High satisfaction with the friendly and efficient service from staff + Staff are frequently praised for their friendliness and smooth check-in process
+ Comfortable bedding and pleasant bathroom conditions + Parking located on the same floor as the rooms offers great convenience
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Rooms are somewhat compact, making it difficult to store or unpack luggage - Some guests reported a musty odor in certain rooms
- Limited storage space or underwhelming views in some rooms - Opinions exist regarding inconsistent cleaning standards
- The selection of basic amenities can feel limited

Recommended For

Shoppers and City Explorers Couples and Families

Recommended For

Family travelers Travelers with cars Long-term guests

Guest Reviews

Holiday Inn Melbourne Bourke Street Mall By IHG

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Great location, close to shopping and transport, perfect for exploring on foot.

Agoda 10.0 Family

The hotel is new, clean, and modern. Staff are very friendly and helpful.

Booking.com 4.0

Perfect location, very clean and modern rooms.

Hard to get luggage to taxi as reception isn’t at street level.

Agoda 8.4 Family

Staff are friendly and have a good impression.

Storage space is limited and the room feels small for luggage.

Punthill Caroline Springs

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Very clean room and well-equipped kitchen facilities.

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Parking on the same floor as the room is very convenient.

Some noise from neighbors

Booking.com 4.0

Great location, quiet and comfortable room.

Pillows were too soft

Booking.com 3.2

Spacious rooms and good value for money.

Musty odor and inconsistent cleaning

Location Comparison

Distance: 20.9km

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.