Hotel O Bidara Guest House vs Persona Boutique Hotel

Same City · Malacca Distance: 24.2km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Hotel O Bidara Guest House

★★ 2-Star
4.6 331
Malacca
View Details →

Persona Boutique Hotel

★★ 2-Star
6.3 34
Malacca
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Hotel O Bidara ... Persona Boutiqu...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Hotel O Bidara ... Persona Boutiqu...
Agoda
4.6 (332)
6.3 (34)
Booking.com
2.1 (29)
5.9 (146)
Expedia
9.0 (2)
6.0
Trip.com
-
6.1 (5)
Overall Average
4.6 (363)
6.3 (185)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Hotel O Bidara Guest House Persona Boutique Hotel
Strengths Strengths
+ A few reviews acknowledge basic cleanliness and value for the low price + Many reviews praise the walkable distance to malls and hospital
+ Free parking satisfies drivers
+ Easy access to nearby convenience stores and eateries is repeated
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Hidden charges via on-site vending machine payment and deposit deductions after online booking are repeatedly complained about - Dust, cockroaches, sewer smells in rooms noted in multiple cleanliness complaints
- Advertised as private bathroom but actually shared, per many reviews - Poor soundproofing lets noise from adjacent rooms through repeatedly
- Rooms are cramped, dirty, lack towels/soap, and noisy - Toilet doors don't lock, missing sheets or amenities frequently mentioned

Recommended For

Solo travelers

Recommended For

Budget travelers Drivers shopping Short stayers

Guest Reviews

Hotel O Bidara Guest House

Booking.com 0.4 Solo traveler

Deposit deducted for hidden charge without prior notice

Booking.com 0.4

Advertised private bath but shared, extra RM10 charge

Agoda 3.6 Family with teens

Differs from photos, bathroom outside room shared

Agoda 4.8 Couple

Dusty room, no towels, thin walls noise

Expedia 8.0

Basic clean, good value for price

Persona Boutique Hotel

Trip.com 10 Family

Clean hotel close to mall and Melaka Central

Agoda 9.6 Family with young children

Staff very friendly and helpful

Agoda 6.4 Couple

Easy to find food near mall

No bedsheet, staff don't speak English

Booking.com 2.4

1 min walk to mall

Poor soundproofing and weak AC

Trip.com 6.5 Family

Dirty dusty room with strong sewer smell

Location Comparison

Distance: 24.2km

Hotel O Bidara Guest House View Details → Persona Boutique Hotel View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.