Hotel SIMIZU vs Matsudai Tanada House

Same City · Tōkamachi Distance: 13.8km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Hotel SIMIZU

★★ 2-Star
6.6 28
Tōkamachi
View Details →

Matsudai Tanada House

★★★★ 4-Star
8.3 40
Tōkamachi
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Hotel SIMIZU Matsudai Tanada...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking
라쿠텐트래블 Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Hotel SIMIZU Matsudai Tanada...
Agoda
6.9 (150)
8.4 (105)
Booking.com
6.6 (92)
8.6 (49)
Expedia
-
7.8 (6)
Trip.com
-
8.6 (6)
Overall Average
6.6 (242)
8.3 (166)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Hotel SIMIZU Matsudai Tanada House
Strengths Strengths
+ Breakfast is delicious with free refills, highly satisfying in reviews + Staff are very kind, with reviews mentioning snow pickups and station drop-offs
+ Staff are friendly and flexible with late arrivals + Rooms and facilities are clean, repeated in reviews
+ Rooms are spacious with tatami traditional style that's well-liked + Breakfast made with local ingredients is delicious and thoughtful
+ Smoking-allowed rooms are convenient for smokers + Convenient access to Echigo-Tsumari Art Field and ski slopes
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Cigarette smell or mold complaints in reviews - Poor soundproofing, neighbor noises heard in several reviews
- Aged facilities with AC and cleanliness issues - 15-20 min walk from station, feels remote
- No elevator, 10-20 min walk to station feels unsafe at night - Some rooms mentioned for odors or bugs

Recommended For

Couples Business travelers Smokers Traditional style lovers

Recommended For

Art Tourists Skiers Nature Lovers

Guest Reviews

Hotel SIMIZU

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Hearty miso soup and sides with refills, very satisfying

Agoda 6.8 Couple

Friendly response to late arrival, tasty breakfast

Agoda 4.0 Couple

Overwhelmed by cigarette smell and bathroom mold

Agoda 10.0 Solo

Spacious tatami room and convenient location

Booking.com 4.0 Solo

Spacious room and delicious breakfast

Matsudai Tanada House

Booking.com 4.0 Solo

Manager picked up in snow and dropped at station

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Had whole space, clean showers, friendly staff

Booking.com 8.6 Couple

Clean with privacy

Agoda 9.2 Family

Minimal but thoughtful facilities and meals

Expedia 8.0 Family

Bunk beds fun

Poor guardrails, neighbor noise

Location Comparison

Distance: 13.8km

Hotel SIMIZU View Details → Matsudai Tanada House View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.