Islander Resort vs Pines & Palms Resort

Same City · Islamorada Distance: 2.7km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Islander Resort

★★★★ 4-Star
9.0 35
Islamorada
View Details →

Pines & Palms Resort

★★★ 3-Star
9.2 14
Islamorada
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Islander Resort Pines & Palms R...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Islander Resort Pines & Palms R...
Agoda
8.9 (1,574)
9.2 (788)
Booking.com
8.8 (1,348)
9.3 (626)
Expedia
9.4 (1,011)
9.2 (1,001)
Trip.com
8.9 (101)
9.0 (99)
Overall Average
9.0 (4,034)
9.2 (2,514)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Islander Resort Pines & Palms Resort
Strengths Strengths
+ Near-9 ratings across booking sites + Rooms are clean and beautifully remodeled, repeated across sites
+ Abundant reviews build trust + Free bikes and kayaks are convenient and fun, many mentions
+ Couples love it + Friendly staff and clean pool commonly praised
+ Well-equipped kitchenettes great for cooking
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Road noise in back buildings mentioned
- AC struggles to cool rooms
- Loud pool music noise noted

Recommended For

Couples Pairs

Recommended For

Couples Groups Families with teens

Guest Reviews

Islander Resort

Expedia 9.4 Couple

High satisfaction

Agoda 8.9 Couple

Steady ratings

Booking.com 8.8 Couple

Most reviews positive

Pines & Palms Resort

Expedia 10.0 Couple

Spotless beautiful room. Heated saltwater pool, bikes, kayaks free.

Agoda 8.8 Family with teens

Spacious cute room, beachfront, daily cleaning thorough.

Weak AC

Agoda 9.6 Couple

Large clean apartment-style, bikes kayaks included.

Beach not swimmable

Trip.com 10.0 Couple

Remodeled clean comfortable. Great staff.

Booking.com 9.5 Couple

Updated cottage beautiful clean. Prime location.

Road noise

Location Comparison

Distance: 2.7km

Islander Resort View Details → Pines & Palms Resort View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.