Matecumbe Resort vs Islander Resort

Same City · Islamorada Distance: 9.3km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Matecumbe Resort

★★ 2-Star
8.2 2
Islamorada
View Details →

Islander Resort

★★★★ 4-Star
9.0 35
Islamorada
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Matecumbe Resort Islander Resort
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Matecumbe Resort Islander Resort
Agoda
8.4 (341)
8.9 (1,574)
Booking.com
-
8.8 (1,348)
Expedia
8.8 (110)
9.4 (1,011)
Trip.com
8.5 (54)
8.9 (101)
Overall Average
8.2 (505)
9.0 (4,034)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Matecumbe Resort Islander Resort
Strengths Strengths
+ Spacious rooms with well-equipped kitchens are convenient for families and longer stays + Near-9 ratings across booking sites
+ Outdoor leisure areas, including the pool and garden, are well-maintained + Abundant reviews build trust
+ Visible efforts in ongoing maintenance and cleanliness despite the property's age + Couples love it
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Some guests reported issues with ants in the rooms
- Complaints regarding strong seaweed odor at the beach
- Limited front desk hours can make communication difficult

Recommended For

Families Leisure Travelers

Recommended For

Couples Pairs

Guest Reviews

Matecumbe Resort

Trip.com 10 Other

Awesome pool and well-maintained property

Trip.com 6 Couple

Room in good condition

Ant problem and low water pressure in shower

Trip.com 10 Family

Quiet and clean

Limited office hours made parking issues hard to resolve

Islander Resort

Expedia 9.4 Couple

High satisfaction

Agoda 8.9 Couple

Steady ratings

Booking.com 8.8 Couple

Most reviews positive

Location Comparison

Distance: 9.3km

Matecumbe Resort View Details → Islander Resort View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.