Melaleuca Lodge vs Nightcap at Ashley Hotel Melaleuca Lodge vs Nightcap at Ashley Hotel
Same City · Melbourne
Distance: 55.3km
Overview
vs
Melaleuca Lodge
Melaleuca Lodge
★★★
3-Star
7.0
148 reviews
Melbourne
Property Type: Hotel
Room Size: -
Nightcap at Ashley Hotel
Nightcap at Ashley Hotel
★★★
3-Star
7.5
100 reviews
Melbourne
Property Type: Hotel
Room Size: -
Live Price Comparison
| Site | Melaleuca Lodge Melaleuca Lodge | Nightcap at Ash... Nightcap at Ashley Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Agoda | Checking | Checking |
| Booking.com | Checking | Checking |
| Expedia | Checking | Checking |
| Trip.com | Checking | Checking |
Rating Comparison by Booking Site
| Site | Melaleuca Lodge Melaleuca Lodge | Nightcap at Ash... Nightcap at Ashley Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Agoda |
6.9
(182)
|
7.5
(349)
|
| Overall Average |
7.0
(182)
|
7.5
(349)
|
Strengths & Weaknesses
| Melaleuca Lodge Melaleuca Lodge | Nightcap at Ashley Hotel Nightcap at Ashley Hotel |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Strengths |
| + Management is friendly and offers flexible check-in services | + Guests frequently mention that rooms and shared bathrooms are kept clean |
| + Rooms and bathrooms are spacious and generally well-maintained | + Comfortable bedding and large TVs are highlighted as positive aspects for relaxation |
| + Located in a natural forest setting, providing a quiet and peaceful atmosphere | + Free parking is a significant convenience for guests traveling by car |
| + Staff are often described as friendly and helpful during the check-in process | |
| Weaknesses | Weaknesses |
| - Facilities are aging and in need of renovation | - Recurring complaints about a stale cigarette odor in some rooms |
| - Occasional maintenance issues such as inconsistent hot water supply in some rooms | - Some rooms do not have private bathrooms, which can be inconvenient |
| - No breakfast service and limited nearby amenities | - Some guests expressed dissatisfaction with the maintenance of the parking area or the surrounding environment |
Recommended For
Solo travelers
Travelers with vehicles
|
Recommended For
Families
Road-trippers
|
Guest Reviews
Melaleuca Lodge
Melaleuca Lodge
Agoda
8.8
Solo traveler
Natural forest setting and clean, spacious rooms
Agoda
9.6
Family
Very clean despite the age of the property, and the manager is very helpful
Agoda
4.4
Solo traveler
Clean bed sheets
Dated facilities, difficult front door, and in need of renovation
Nightcap at Ashley Hotel
Nightcap at Ashley Hotel
Agoda
10.0
Couple
Staff were lovely at check-in, room was clean, and had everything needed for a night.
Agoda
5.2
Couple
Room was neat and tidy.
Absolutely stunk of 2nd hand cigarette smoke, which was off-putting for a non-smoker.
Agoda
5.6
Solo
Shared bathrooms are actually very clean compared to many other places in Australia. Rooms are spacious.
Location Comparison
Distance: 55.3km
This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.