MSTAY東池袋one vs Smile Hotel Tokyo Asagaya

Same City · Tokyo Distance: 8.4km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

MSTAY東池袋one

★★ 2-Star
8.7 17
Tokyo
View Details →

Smile Hotel Tokyo Asagaya

★★★ 3-Star
8.0 4,192
Tokyo
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site MSTAY東池袋one Smile Hotel Tok...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking
라쿠텐트래블 Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site MSTAY東池袋one Smile Hotel Tok...
Agoda
8.6 (19)
7.8 (4,669)
Booking.com
-
7.5 (698)
Expedia
-
8.0 (1,000)
Trip.com
-
8.4 (119)
Overall Average
8.7 (19)
8.0 (6,486)

Strengths & Weaknesses

MSTAY東池袋one Smile Hotel Tokyo Asagaya
Strengths Strengths
+ Groups frequently note it's very clean with all necessary facilities + Right next to station, easy access in any weather repeated in reviews
+ Comfortable beds and spacious enough for groups mentioned repeatedly + Nearby food alleys and convenience stores make eating and shopping convenient
+ Nearby supermarkets and cafes make daily life convenient + Friendly staff and clean rooms commonly praised
+ Practical kitchen and washing machine praised in many reviews + Minimal train noise and comfortable beds frequently mentioned
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Winter heating shortage and cold showers noted as issues by families - Rooms and bathrooms small and building dated complaints repeated
- No bedroom partitions and lack of shower privacy pointed out - Cleaning issues, dust, odors pointed out in reviews
- Difficult to open entrance door and key delivery errors reported - Some rooms have noise or smells from surroundings

Recommended For

Group travelers Business or shopping travelers Budget-conscious travelers

Recommended For

Solo travelers Couples Families Groups

Guest Reviews

MSTAY東池袋one

Agoda 9.6 Group

Clean and fully equipped

Lack of shower privacy

Agoda 9.6 Group

Very clean, walkable to Otsuka Station

Agoda 5.6 Family with young children

Good location and cheap

Poor winter heating, cold shower

Booking.com 4.0 Solo

Very clean, close to needs

Booking.com 3.2 Family

Quiet local vibe

No dryer, low doorways

Smile Hotel Tokyo Asagaya

Agoda 9.6 Group

Right by JR station, near convenience stores malls restaurants, clean rooms

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Cheapest option but clean, friendly staff, subway next door

Expedia 10.0 Couple

Felt like home, good location and great staff accommodations

Booking.com 8.0 Solo

Next to station no noise, plenty of food bars nearby

Small room

Trip.com 10.0 Family

Best access to Asagaya station, minimal noise room fits luggage

Location Comparison

Distance: 8.4km

MSTAY東池袋one View Details → Smile Hotel Tokyo Asagaya View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.