Rodeway Inn Williamsburg Historic Area vs Capt. John Smith Inn Williamsburg

Same City · Williamsburg (VA) Distance: 4.5km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Rodeway Inn Williamsburg Historic Area

★★ 2-Star
7.7 14
Williamsburg (VA)
View Details →

Capt. John Smith Inn Williamsburg

★★ 2-Star
8.0 51
Williamsburg (VA)
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Rodeway Inn Wil... Capt. John Smit...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Rodeway Inn Wil... Capt. John Smit...
Agoda
7.6 (19)
7.8 (59)
Booking.com
6.6 (635)
6.6 (95)
Expedia
7.6 (1,004)
6.2 (844)
Trip.com
7.1 (97)
6.2 (43)
Overall Average
7.7 (1,755)
8.0 (1,041)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Rodeway Inn Williamsburg Historic Area Capt. John Smith Inn Williamsburg
Strengths Strengths
+ Many reviews say walking distance to historic area makes sightseeing easy + Rooms are consistently described as clean and well-maintained
+ Rooms are spacious and clean repeatedly mentioned + Staff are highly praised for being friendly and treating guests like family
+ Nearby pancake house and restaurants are practical + Convenient location for accessing major attractions and outlets
+ Easy parking and quiet per reviews + High value for money, making it suitable for budget-conscious travelers
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Heating broken, only space heater provided, rooms cold on chilly days common complaint - Mentions of facility aging due to the building's age
- Breakfast not as advertised, just coffee/donuts or none repeated regret - Reports of inconsistent pool availability or maintenance
- Some rooms noted roaches, smells, hair from poor cleaning - Occasional complaints regarding soundproofing or equipment functionality in some rooms

Recommended For

Budget travelers Sightseers Couples

Recommended For

Budget-conscious travelers Families

Guest Reviews

Rodeway Inn Williamsburg Historic Area

Trip.com 2 Family

Unfriendly staff, room full of roaches, bad smell, hair everywhere disappointing

Trip.com 4 Couple

Room condition ok, fits location

No heat, only space heater, wore winter coats inside

Agoda 9.6 Couple

Great room, breakfast, convenient location, cheap recommend

Booking.com 2.4 Solo

Good location, spacious room

Breakfast only coffee not as advertised

Booking.com 3.2 Solo

Great location, clean safe

Needs maintenance, weak heat

Capt. John Smith Inn Williamsburg

Agoda 10.0 Family with kids

The hotel is unique, lovely, and clean, and the owners are very kind.

Trip.com 10.0 Business

Great staff, cleanliness, and accommodations; they treat you like family.

Booking.com 3.2 Family

Rooms were clean and the AC was working well for the price.

Booking.com 2.8 Other

Good value and location.

The pool was not open.

Location Comparison

Distance: 4.5km

Rodeway Inn Williamsburg Historic Area View Details → Capt. John Smith Inn Williamsburg View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.