ROGUES HARBOR INN BED AND BREAKFAST vs Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca

Same City · Ithaca Distance: 10.8km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

ROGUES HARBOR INN BED AND BREAKFAST

★★★ 3-Star
9.8 2
Ithaca
View Details →

Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca

★★★ 3-Star
8.9 40
Ithaca
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site ROGUES HARBOR I... Hilton Garden I...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site ROGUES HARBOR I... Hilton Garden I...
Agoda
9.8 (2)
8.8 (46)
Booking.com
-
8.5 (278)
Expedia
8.8 (198)
9.0 (1,010)
Trip.com
8.8 (34)
8.7 (41)
Overall Average
9.8 (234)
8.9 (1,375)

Strengths & Weaknesses

ROGUES HARBOR INN BED AND BREAKFAST Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca
Strengths Strengths
+ Consistently high praise for the delicious, freshly prepared breakfast + Excellent accessibility to restaurants and shops near Ithaca Commons
+ A perfect balance between historic charm and well-maintained modern interiors + Rooms are consistently described as spacious, clean, and comfortable
+ Friendly, attentive staff and excellent communication + Free parking in the downtown area is a major convenience for guests
+ Convenient on-site pub for dining and drinks + Staff are frequently noted for being friendly and helpful
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Some reports of slow bathroom sink drainage in certain rooms - Some reports of a mild mildewy or strange odor in rooms
- Some guests find the mattresses to be too firm - Breakfast service can be disorganized with long wait times
- Recreational facilities like the pool may be unavailable due to maintenance

Recommended For

Couples History Enthusiasts

Recommended For

Cornell University visitors Travelers with cars

Guest Reviews

ROGUES HARBOR INN BED AND BREAKFAST

Expedia 10.0 Other

The complimentary breakfast blew me away and completely exceeded expectations. Fresh and delicious.

Trip.com 10.0 Couple

The building was excellently maintained, and furnishings/decor struck the perfect balance between period and modern.

Trip.com 8.0 Other

The service was great -- catering to my wife's dietary needs with flourish.

The only down side was the bathroom sink in room 8 was slow to drain.

Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca

Trip.com 10 Business

Spacious, clean, and convenient parking. Close to Cornell University.

Agoda 10 Couple

Close to Ithaca Commons with many great restaurants nearby.

Booking.com 3.2

Great location and free parking.

Pool was out of order.

Booking.com 2.8

Clean rooms.

Breakfast was overpriced and disorganized.

Location Comparison

Distance: 10.8km

ROGUES HARBOR INN BED AND BREAKFAST View Details → Hilton Garden Inn Ithaca View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.