Star City Hotel vs The Secret Garden Guesthouse

Same City · Hong Kong Distance: 0.4km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Star City Hotel

★ 1-Star
6.5 61
Hong Kong
View Details →

The Secret Garden Guesthouse

★★★ 3-Star
6.9 39
Hong Kong
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Star City Hotel The Secret Gard...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Star City Hotel The Secret Gard...
Agoda
6.7 (161)
6.7 (69)
Booking.com
6.5 (15)
-
Expedia
5.4 (33)
-
Overall Average
6.5 (209)
6.9 (69)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Star City Hotel The Secret Garden Guesthouse
Strengths Strengths
+ Great Tsim Sha Tsui location near subway, malls, and harbor for easy access, as many reviews note + Right at the subway exit for easy TST access
+ Staff are friendly and helpful in resolving issues, repeated in reviews + Self check-in makes check-in/out simple
+ Small but cozy rooms with good value for the location + Host responds quickly and is friendly
+ Affordable for short stays
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Building under renovation causes noise, hard-to-find entrance, and sketchy people around - Room is narrow with no storage or desk
- Cleanliness issues like sewer smells and hair repeated - Slippery bathroom floor causes falls
- Small rooms without windows, broken TV/fridge in some cases - Toilet leaks and no window lets odors linger

Recommended For

Budget travelers Short-stay tourists Solo travelers

Recommended For

Couples Short-term business travelers

Guest Reviews

Star City Hotel

Agoda 8.4 Couple

Good value for location, friendly staff. Small but cozy room.

Agoda 6.4 Solo

Good location.

Broken TV/fridge, noisy, expensive water.

Agoda 2.8 Couple

Taken to wrong hotel, dirty room and noise.

Booking.com 3.2 Mixed

Amazing location, helpful staff.

Construction noise, slippery bathroom.

Expedia 2.0 Mixed

Persistent sewer smell.

The Secret Garden Guesthouse

Agoda 7.6 Couple

Convenient location near subway, easy self check-in, quick host response

Late check-in, narrow room, poor towel quality, wet bathroom after shower

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Clean and good location, friendly host

Agoda 4.8 Couple

Slippery bathroom caused fall, toilet leak, no window odor issue

Agoda 2.0 Business

Check-in delay and booking issues, toilet noise, smelly sheets

Location Comparison

Distance: 0.4km

Star City Hotel View Details → The Secret Garden Guesthouse View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.