The Knickerbocker Hotel vs The Broome Hotel

Same City · New York Distance: 4.0km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

The Knickerbocker Hotel

★★★★★ 5-Star
9.0 278
New York
View Details →

The Broome Hotel

★★★★ 4-Star
8.8 19
New York
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site The Knickerbock... The Broome Hotel
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site The Knickerbock... The Broome Hotel
Agoda
8.8 (3,015)
8.8 (19)
Booking.com
8.4 (2,155)
-
Expedia
9.2 (1,802)
-
Trip.com
8.7 (137)
8.7 (88)
Overall Average
9.0 (7,109)
8.8 (107)

Strengths & Weaknesses

The Knickerbocker Hotel The Broome Hotel
Strengths Strengths
+ Consistently high ratings + Reviews repeatedly praise the central SoHo location for easy access to shopping, dining, and subways
+ Satisfies various guest types + Staff noted for being friendly and providing attentive service
+ 5-star standard + Breakfast praised as delicious in a cozy cafe-like space
+ Boutique style with cute and charming rooms frequently mentioned
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Ongoing renovations mentioned as causing some inconvenience and noise
- Rooms small with lacking amenities like fridge or coffee maker
- Some feel poor value for the price

Recommended For

Couple Family

Recommended For

Couples Solo travelers Business travelers

Guest Reviews

The Knickerbocker Hotel

Expedia 9.2 Couple
Booking.com 8.4 Couple
Trip.com 8.7 Couple
Agoda 8.8 Couple

The Broome Hotel

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Friendly staff, cute pretty room. Great location and breakfast.

Agoda 9.6 Couple

Heart of SoHo near subway. Great staff, courtyard cafe breakfast.

Agoda 8.0 Couple

Excellent staff, minimal construction noise.

Carpet stains

Trip.com 10.0 Business

Super friendly helpful staff. Tidy rooms great location.

Trip.com 8.0 Other

Soho location near restaurants shopping subway. Helpful staff.

Sparse in-room amenities

Location Comparison

Distance: 4.0km

The Knickerbocker Hotel View Details → The Broome Hotel View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.