Valued Stay Mayflower vs Comfort Suites Madison West - Middleton

Same City · Madison Distance: 11.7km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Valued Stay Mayflower

★★ 2-Star
6.9 4
Madison
View Details →

Comfort Suites Madison West - Middleton

★★ 2-Star
9.0 134
Madison
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Valued Stay May... Comfort Suites ...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Valued Stay May... Comfort Suites ...
Agoda
7.2 (5)
8.8 (159)
Booking.com
6.2 (55)
7.8 (227)
Expedia
6.2 (412)
8.0 (486)
Trip.com
6.0 (65)
7.9 (103)
Overall Average
6.9 (537)
9.0 (975)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Valued Stay Mayflower Comfort Suites Madison West - Middleton
Strengths Strengths
+ Friendly staff mentioned repeatedly across sites + Frequent mentions of spacious rooms and comfortable beds
+ Clean rooms and comfortable beds praised often + Well-maintained pool and hot tub facilities are highly appreciated
+ Convenient outside doors and single-level access noted + Staff members are consistently described as friendly and helpful
+ Good location for Madison sites common feedback
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- No temperature control, rooms too hot repeated complaint - Some guests report weak soundproofing between rooms
- Rundown exterior and sketchy neighborhood noted - The property is described as showing its age
- Shower mold and no soap issues mentioned

Recommended For

Business travelers Budget travelers Solo travelers

Recommended For

Families Value-conscious travelers

Guest Reviews

Valued Stay Mayflower

Expedia 8.0 Couple

Nice staff and clean room

Booking.com 2.0 Family

Comfortable bed and clean

No temp control and shower mold

Agoda 8.4 Solo

Great value and comfortable

Trip.com 8.0 Business

Convenient outside doors and location

Trip.com 6.0 Business

Friendly service

Room doesn't match photos, needs TLC

Comfort Suites Madison West - Middleton

Agoda 9.6 Couple

Staff was very polite; pool and hot tub were fantastic.

Agoda 10.0 Family

Rooms are clean, spacious, and breakfast options are excellent.

Booking.com 2.8 Other

Convenient parking and large rooms.

Trash outside and noise issues.

Trip.com 8.0 Other

Great breakfast and good location.

Thin walls lead to noise from neighboring rooms.

Location Comparison

Distance: 11.7km

Valued Stay Mayflower View Details → Comfort Suites Madison West - Middleton View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.