Key West
·
Accommodation
Banana's Foster Guesthouse - Key West Accommodation
8.2/10
Hotel Analysis
Based on 2 sites · 16 reviews
Located near Duval Street, the heart of Key West, this guesthouse offers a historic atmosphere in a building dating back to the 1800s. Its prime location makes it an ideal base for travelers who want to explore the main attractions on foot.
Guests generally appreciate the cleanliness of the rooms. The well-maintained interiors and cozy porches are frequently highlighted as positive aspects. It is a preferred choice for those looking to experience the vibrant energy of Key West.
However, due to the age of the building, soundproofing is not perfect, and nighttime noise can be expected. As the property operates with minimal staff presence, communication regarding check-in or amenities can sometimes be challenging, making it better suited for travelers who prefer an independent stay.
Strengths
Excellent accessibility to major attractions near Duval Street
Rooms are generally kept clean and well-maintained
Cozy porch areas provide a nice space for relaxation
Good to Know
Soundproofing is weak due to the age of the building
Lack of on-site staff can make check-in and amenity requests difficult
Some complaints regarding aging facilities and missing amenities
Recommended For
Walkers — Located near Duval Street, making it easy to reach major attractions on foot
Independent Travelers — Suitable for those who prefer a stay without staff interaction
Ratings by Booking Site
Overall 8.2/10 · 1 sites · Based on 16 reviews
Guest Reviews
1 booking sites · 16 reviews
Frequently Mentioned
Location
Cleanliness
Noise
Communication
10.0
·
Expedia
·
Couple
Expedia
·
Couple
+
Perfect location near Duval St, cute room with a nice porch.
6.0
·
Expedia
·
Family
Expedia
·
Family
-
Old building, poor soundproofing, and aging facilities.
10.0
·
Expedia
·
Solo
Expedia
·
Solo
+
The room was spotless and very comfortable.
Nearby
Google MapsLoading map...
FAQ
It is located very close to Duval Street, making it highly convenient for walking to major attractions.
As it is an old building from the 1800s, soundproofing is not perfect. You may experience noise at night.
There is often no staff on-site, which can sometimes make communication regarding check-in or amenities difficult.
Most guests rate the rooms as very clean and well-maintained.
While the location is great, the noise issues and lack of on-site staff may be inconvenient for families seeking a quiet stay.
