Put-in-Bay Commodore Resort - Real Guest Reviews & Booking Info

  • ✓ Ratings from 4 booking sites
  • ✓ 3-Star Accommodation in Put-in-Bay
Live Price Compare In-depth Hotel Analysis Real Guest Reviews
Put-in-Bay Commodore Resort 3-Star Accommodation room
1 / 20
Put-in-Bay · Accommodation ·

Commodore Resort - Put-in-Bay 3-Star Accommodation

6.7/10
Expedia 6.8 · Trip.com 6.6 · Booking.com 4.1
Check-in 17:00 | Check-out 11:00

Hotel Analysis

Based on 4 sites · 577 reviews

Located in the heart of Put-in-Bay, Ohio, this 3-star resort is primarily praised by guests for its central location, which allows for easy access to major local attractions on foot.

Strengths

Excellent central location in Put-in-Bay with easy walking access to major attractions and amenities

Good to Know

Frequent complaints regarding musty odors and unclean floors in rooms

Recurring reports of poor soundproofing and uncomfortable mattresses

Inconvenient check-in process and inconsistent management responsiveness

Recommended For

Location-focused travelers — Suitable for travelers who prioritize proximity to attractions and use the room primarily for sleeping

Ratings by Booking Site

Overall 6.7/10 · 4 sites · Based on 577 reviews

Guest Reviews

4 booking sites · 577 reviews

Frequently Mentioned

Location Cleanliness Smell Soundproofing
8.0 · Expedia · Other
+ Great location downtown and affordable
- Limited parking and cleanliness issues
2.0 · Trip.com · Couple
- Musty smell in the room and damaged bathroom tiles
See All 577 Reviews
Expedia 462 Trip.com 95 Agoda 10 Booking.com 10

Nearby

Google Maps

Loading map...

Beer Barrel Saloon

Beer Barrel Saloon

4.4 (718)
Restaurant 63m
Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery

Put-in-Bay Brewery and Distillery

4.4 (329)
Restaurant 102m
Hooligans Irish Pub

Hooligans Irish Pub

4.5 (961)
Restaurant 105m
The Forge

The Forge

4.5 (587)
Restaurant 116m
Reel Bar - Put-In-Bay, OH

Reel Bar - Put-In-Bay, OH

4.5 (561)
Restaurant 124m
Mossbacks Island Grill and The Fishbowl Bar

Mossbacks Island Grill and The Fishbowl Bar

4.5 (655)
Restaurant 154m
The Roundhouse Bar

The Roundhouse Bar

4.6 (1,172)
Restaurant 156m
Blue Marlin Tiki Bar & Grill

Blue Marlin Tiki Bar & Grill

4.3 (152)
Restaurant 199m
The Boardwalk

The Boardwalk

4.5 (2,225)
Restaurant 214m
Biergarten at the Boathouse

Biergarten at the Boathouse

4.8 (91)
Restaurant 305m
The Boathouse Bar and Grill

The Boathouse Bar and Grill

4.4 (1,193)
Restaurant 308m
The Sand Bar

The Sand Bar

4.4 (382)
Restaurant 311m
Margaritas on the Rock

Margaritas on the Rock

4.4 (238)
Restaurant 366m
The Keys | Put-in-Bay

The Keys | Put-in-Bay

4.4 (706)
Restaurant 425m
DanDee's Snack Shack

DanDee's Snack Shack

4.5 (11)
Restaurant 919m

FAQ

Yes, it is located in the heart of the city, offering excellent walking access to major attractions and amenities.

Many guests have expressed concerns about musty odors and the cleanliness of the floors. It is worth noting if you are sensitive to hygiene.

If on-site staff are unavailable, you may need to check in at a nearby bar. It is recommended to contact the property in advance.

Some reviews mention poor soundproofing. As it is located in a busy area, external noise can be an issue, so earplugs are recommended for light sleepers.

Children do not stay for free and additional fees may apply. Given the mixed reviews on room maintenance, it is advisable to compare with other options for family trips.

$88 / night
Best Price