New York Garden City Hotel - Real Guest Reviews & Booking Info

  • ✓ Ratings from 4 booking sites
  • ✓ 4-Star Accommodation in New York
Live Price Compare In-depth Hotel Analysis Real Guest Reviews
New York Garden City Hotel 4-Star Accommodation room
1 / 5
New York · Accommodation ·

Garden City Hotel - New York 4-Star Accommodation

9.1/10
Expedia 9.4 · Trip.com 9.0 · Agoda 8.9 · Booking.com 8.4
Check-in 16:00 | Check-out 11:00

Hotel Analysis

Based on 4 sites · 1,514 reviews

Located in the heart of Garden City, New York, this hotel blends classic elegance with modern amenities. Guests consistently praise the spacious, comfortable rooms and the professional, friendly service. The surrounding area is quiet and walkable, making it a popular choice for those seeking a relaxing getaway.

Strengths

Rooms are frequently described as spacious, comfortable, and well-maintained.

Staff members are highly professional, friendly, and responsive to guest needs.

The surrounding area is quiet and walkable, creating a relaxing environment.

Good to Know

Some guests mentioned that certain furniture and carpets appear dated.

Elevator wait times can be long during events or weddings.

In-room coffee machines or sufficient amenities are sometimes lacking.

Recommended For

Relaxation-focused travelers — The quiet surroundings and comfortable rooms are ideal for those seeking a peaceful stay.

Business travelers — Professional service and clean, well-appointed rooms make it a reliable choice for business trips.

Ratings by Booking Site

Overall 9.1/10 · 4 sites · Based on 1,514 reviews

Guest Reviews

4 booking sites · 1,514 reviews

Frequently Mentioned

Friendly staff Spacious rooms Dated Noise
10.0 · Expedia · Couple
+ Modern features mixed with antique elegance; professional and accommodating staff.
3.2 · Booking.com · Other
+ Lovely room, great ambiance, and excellent room service.
- Loud noise from wedding guests and long elevator waits.
10.0 · Trip.com · Other
+ Spacious, clean, and comfortable rooms with a walkable location.
See All 1,514 Reviews
Expedia 1,034 Booking.com 310 Trip.com 102 Agoda 68

Nearby

Google Maps

Loading map...

Seventh Street Gourmet

Seventh Street Gourmet

4.7 (134)
Restaurant 292m
Taku Asian Bistro restaurant

Taku Asian Bistro restaurant

4.5 (221)
Restaurant 292m
Tony's Tacos Garden City

Tony's Tacos Garden City

4.8 (606)
Restaurant 358m
il Gufo

il Gufo

4.5 (68)
Restaurant 501m
La Nonna Bella

La Nonna Bella

4.5 (319)
Restaurant 538m
Waterzooi Belgian Bistro & Oyster Bar

Waterzooi Belgian Bistro & Oyster Bar

4.5 (2,018)
Restaurant 564m
My Three Sons Bagel Cafe (Franklin Ave)

My Three Sons Bagel Cafe (Franklin Ave)

4.5 (417)
Restaurant 661m
Plancha

Plancha

4.6 (571)
Restaurant 671m
Kyuramen x TBAAR - Garden City

Kyuramen x TBAAR - Garden City

4.8 (1,491)
Restaurant 675m
NY Soup Exchange

NY Soup Exchange

4.7 (134)
Restaurant 687m
Miso Ramen and Hibachi

Miso Ramen and Hibachi

4.5 (309)
Restaurant 1.6km
The Davenport Press

The Davenport Press

4.6 (480)
Restaurant 1.8km
Youta Ramen

Youta Ramen

4.8 (715)
Restaurant 2.0km
Cala Luna Restaurant

Cala Luna Restaurant

4.8 (161)
Restaurant 2.1km
The Ranch House Restaurant & Bar

The Ranch House Restaurant & Bar

4.8 (167)
Restaurant 2.9km

New York Popular Tours & Activities

View all activities →

This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission.

FAQ

Typically, check-in starts at 3:00 PM and check-out is by 11:00 AM. Please contact the hotel directly for exact times.

Garden City Hotel has received a rating of 8.9/10 from 62 guests.

Recommended Hotels in New York

전체 보기 →
$219 / night
Best Price