New York Gatsby Hotel - Real Guest Reviews & Booking Info

✓ Ratings from 4 booking sites
✓ 3-Star Accommodation in New York

Live Price Compare In-depth Hotel Analysis Real Guest Reviews

New York Gatsby Hotel 3-Star Accommodation room

1 / 5

Reviewed by HotelATG

New York · Accommodation ·

Gatsby Hotel - New York 3-Star Accommodation

Name: Gatsby Hotel
Address: 135 E. Houston Street, New York, US
Price range: ₩400400
Rating: 6.7

7.4/10

Expedia 7.4 · Booking.com 7.4 · Trip.com 7.3 · Agoda 6.7

Check-in 15:00 | Check-out 11:00

Hotel Analysis

Based on 4 sites · 2,449 reviews

Located in the Lower East Side of Manhattan, New York, the Gatsby Hotel is a budget-friendly accommodation within walking distance of major subway stations. The area is dense with restaurants and shops, making it ideal for those who want to experience the vibrant atmosphere of New York.

Strengths

Very convenient for getting around Manhattan due to proximity to major subway stations

Located in the heart of the Lower East Side with great access to nearby restaurants and shops

Many reviews mention that the staff is friendly and responsive

Maintains a clean room condition relative to the price

Good to Know

Rooms are small and facilities feel generally worn out

Occasional issues with hot water supply or malfunctioning equipment

Poor soundproofing makes corridor and street noise audible

Recommended For

Budget-conscious travelers — Suitable for travelers who want to stay in the heart of Manhattan at a reasonable price.

Walkers — Great for travelers who frequently move on foot due to proximity to subway stations and local attractions.

Ratings by Booking Site

Overall 7.5/10 · 4 sites · Based on 2,449 reviews

Guest Reviews

4 booking sites · 2,449 reviews

Frequently Mentioned

Location Friendly staff Small rooms Noise Worn-out facilities

8.8 ·

Agoda · Group

+ Optimal location for downtown access and clean room condition.

8.0 ·

Expedia · Solo traveler

+ A good choice if you are looking for a clean, safe place near the subway.

- I recommend bringing your own soap and shampoo.

3.6 ·

Booking.com · Other

+ Excellent subway accessibility and reasonable price.

- Soundproofing is poor, so external noise is audible.

See All 2,449 Reviews

Nearby

Google Maps

Loading map...

New York Popular Tours & Activities

View all activities →

Niagara Falls Day Tour from New York

4.3 · 194 reviews

$268~

Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island Half Day Tour with Audio Guide

4.1 · 175 reviews

Check price

Statue of Liberty Express Cruise Tour in New York

4.7 · 139 reviews

$29~

Experience Statue of Liberty with Various Tour Options

4.4 · 129 reviews

$29~

Contrast of NYC: Bronx, Brooklyn, Harlem, Queens & Coney Island

4.5 · 81 reviews

$84~

Woodbury Common Premium Outlets Shopping Tour

4.4 · 78 reviews

$55~

This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission.

FAQ

Yes, it is within walking distance to major subway stations, making it very convenient for getting around Manhattan.

Some guests have reported issues with hot water supply. We recommend checking the hot water in your room immediately after check-in.

The hotel is located in the Lower East Side, an area dense with various restaurants, cafes, and shops, making it an excellent location for dining.

Some guests have noted that soundproofing is somewhat weak. You may hear noise from the hallway or the street, so please keep this in mind if you are sensitive to noise.

Basic amenities are provided, but some guests recommend bringing your own soap or shampoo based on personal preference.