Shelter Island (NY) House on Chase Creek - Real Guest Reviews & Booking Info

  • ✓ Ratings from 4 booking sites
  • ✓ 4-Star Accommodation in Shelter Island (NY)
Live Price Compare In-depth Hotel Analysis Real Guest Reviews
Shelter Island (NY) House on Chase Creek 4-Star Accommodation room
1 / 20
Shelter Island (NY) · Accommodation ·

House on Chase Creek - Shelter Island (NY) 4-Star Accommodation

9.4/10
Expedia 9.4 · Trip.com 9.4 · Booking.com 9.1
Check-in 15:00 | Check-out 11:00

Hotel Analysis

Based on 4 sites · 173 reviews

Situated along a peaceful creek on Shelter Island, this property retains the charm of an old house while offering modern comforts. It is well-regarded by travelers seeking a quiet and cozy retreat.

Strengths

The host is exceptionally kind and provides helpful local recommendations for dining and sightseeing

The creek-side location offers beautiful views and a peaceful atmosphere

Conveniently located within walking distance of the village center and restaurants

Good to Know

Some guests feel uncomfortable with the unmanned operation regarding security or check-in

Breakfast is not provided, requiring guests to arrange their own meals

There are occasional mentions of dissatisfaction with room cleanliness or maintenance

Recommended For

Couples — The quiet and romantic atmosphere makes it ideal for anniversary trips or relaxing getaways

Nature Lovers — Highly satisfying for travelers who want to enjoy creek views and a garden setting

Check best prices for this hotel $118부터 / 1박

Ratings by Booking Site

Overall 9.3/10 · 4 sites · Based on 173 reviews

Guest Reviews

4 booking sites · 173 reviews

Frequently Mentioned

Friendly host Peaceful atmosphere Great location No breakfast Security concerns
10.0 · Expedia · Couple
+ Visited for our anniversary; the host's hospitality and creek-side location were wonderful.
4.0 · Booking.com · Other
+ Charming, cozy atmosphere and very convenient to walk to town.
2.8 · Booking.com · Other
+ Location and views are lovely.
- Unmanned operation raises security concerns and no breakfast is provided.
10.0 · Trip.com · Other
+ Spacious, clean rooms with beautiful antique decor.
See All 173 Reviews
Expedia 81 Agoda 45 Trip.com 32 Booking.com 15

Nearby

Google Maps

Loading map...

The 1901 Grill

The 1901 Grill

4.7 (23)
Restaurant 630m
The Eccentric Bagel

The Eccentric Bagel

4.7 (114)
Restaurant 746m
Chez Marie

Chez Marie

4.7 (12)
Restaurant 1.1km
Opties and Dinghies

Opties and Dinghies

4.9 (147)
Restaurant 1.2km
Maria's Kitchen

Maria's Kitchen

4.7 (209)
Restaurant 1.6km
Lucharitos

Lucharitos

4.5 (1,142)
Restaurant 2.3km
Sterlington Deli

Sterlington Deli

4.5 (423)
Restaurant 2.3km
CASA AMIGOS Restaurante

CASA AMIGOS Restaurante

4.5 (141)
Restaurant 2.4km
Nookies

Nookies

4.8 (75)
Restaurant 2.4km
The Boathouse

The Boathouse

4.7 (10)
Restaurant 2.4km
Ellen's on Front

Ellen's on Front

4.6 (182)
Restaurant 2.4km
Shelter Island Slice

Shelter Island Slice

4.8 (145)
Restaurant 2.4km
Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market

Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market

4.8 (486)
Restaurant 2.4km
First and South Restaurant & Bar

First and South Restaurant & Bar

4.5 (464)
Restaurant 2.5km
American Beech Restaurant

American Beech Restaurant

4.9 (86)
Restaurant 2.5km

United States Travel Essentials

Sort these out before you land — it makes the trip smoother

Airalo eSIM
eSIMs for 200+ countries · activate instantly in-app

This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission.

FAQ

Typically, check-in starts at 3:00 PM and check-out is by 11:00 AM. Please contact the hotel directly for exact times.

House on Chase Creek has received a rating of 0.0/10 from 0 guests.

$118 / night
Best Price