Hotel Analysis
Based on 2 sites · 15 reviews
Located in the heart of Manhattan, this guesthouse offers proximity to Madison Square Garden and Penn Station, making it a convenient base for exploring New York. The property is housed in a 1910 building, providing a local apartment-style experience.
Guests frequently highlight the excellent location as the primary benefit, noting the ease of access to public transportation and major city landmarks. Some travelers find the rooms to be a functional and economical option.
However, there are recurring concerns regarding facility maintenance and hygiene. Guests have noted the lack of an elevator in the three-story building, issues with heating and cooling, and cleanliness problems in shared bathrooms. Reports regarding the surrounding neighborhood safety and inconsistent management service suggest that travelers should carefully consider these factors before booking.
Strengths
Excellent location in central Manhattan
Convenient access to public transport near Penn Station
Building structure offers a local NYC apartment experience
Good to Know
No elevator, making it difficult to carry luggage
Hygiene issues and mold in shared bathrooms
Malfunctioning heating/cooling and lack of on-site management
Recommended For
Backpackers — Suitable for those who prioritize location and want to stay in central Manhattan at an economical price.
Ratings by Booking Site
Overall 6.4/10 · 1 sites · Based on 15 reviews
Guest Reviews
1 booking sites · 15 reviews
Frequently Mentioned
Trip.com
·
Couple
Trip.com
·
Other
Nearby
Google MapsLoading map...
New York Popular Tours & Activities
View all activities →This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission.
FAQ
Yes, it is very close to Penn Station, making it easy to access subways and trains. It is an ideal location for traveling to major attractions in Manhattan.
Unfortunately, the building does not have an elevator. You will need to use the stairs, so please keep this in mind if you have heavy luggage.
It depends on the room type, but some rooms require the use of a shared bathroom. As there are mixed reviews regarding hygiene, it is recommended to check the room details before booking.
While it is in a busy area of central Manhattan, some guests have expressed concerns about the environment at night.
Due to the age of the facility, there are reports that the heating and cooling systems may not function consistently. Please be aware that this could cause discomfort depending on the season.




















