Hotel Analysis
Based on 4 sites · 599 reviews
Located across from Madison Square Park in the heart of Manhattan, this 5-star hotel offers a sophisticated, modern aesthetic and a calm atmosphere, serving as an urban retreat. Guests frequently praise the hotel's on-site restaurant and bar for their excellent ambiance.
Across various booking platforms, the hotel is highly regarded for its prime location and design. Guests appreciate the convenience of being within walking distance of major landmarks and local amenities, and the modern, clean room design is often highlighted as a positive feature.
Conversely, some guests point out that the service consistency does not always match the high price point. Issues such as check-in delays, inconsistent room cleanliness, and a lack of clear communication regarding facilities are recurring themes. Many guests also express disappointment over the lack of in-room coffee machines and limited storage space.
Overall, it is an attractive choice for travelers who prioritize location and atmosphere, though those who value consistent service quality relative to price may want to consider these factors.
Strengths
Excellent accessibility in the heart of Manhattan and convenient location near the park
Sophisticated, modern interior design and calm atmosphere
High-quality ambiance and dining at the on-site restaurant and bar
Good to Know
Inconsistent service quality relative to the high price point
Check-in delays and occasional cleanliness issues in rooms
Lack of in-room coffee machines and limited storage space
Recommended For
Couples — Many reviews highlight the hotel's sophisticated atmosphere and the stylish interior of the bar and restaurant as ideal for dates.
City Travelers — Repeated feedback suggests it is the perfect location for walking tours and accessing major Manhattan landmarks.
Ratings by Booking Site
Overall 8.9/10 · 4 sites · Based on 599 reviews
Nearby
Google MapsLoading map...
New York Popular Tours & Activities
View all activities →This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission.
FAQ
Typically, check-in starts at 3:00 PM and check-out is by 11:00 AM. Please contact the hotel directly for exact times.
The New York EDITION has received a rating of 9.2/10 from 14 guests.