Best Western Gregory Hotel vs Sheridan Hotel

Same City · New York Distance: 25.9km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Best Western Gregory Hotel

★★ 2-Star
7.8 91
New York
View Details →

Sheridan Hotel

★★ 2-Star
4.6 39
New York
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Best Western Gr... Sheridan Hotel
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Best Western Gr... Sheridan Hotel
Agoda
7.7 (103)
5.3 (575)
Booking.com
6.8 (1,063)
5.3 (293)
Expedia
7.8 (1,003)
-
Trip.com
6.9 (108)
5.1 (2)
Overall Average
7.8 (2,277)
4.6 (870)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Best Western Gregory Hotel Sheridan Hotel
Strengths Strengths
+ Reviews repeat subway one block away makes Manhattan trips easy + Offers free parking, which is rare in New York City
+ Staff friendliness praised across sites + Relatively close proximity to the subway station
+ Easy access to nearby restaurants and shops noted often
+ Breakfast waffles and options get positive mentions
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Many complaints about broken elevators forcing stairs - Severe hygiene issues in bedding and bathrooms, including pest sightings
- Irregular cleaning and un-replaced toiletries noted - Safety concerns due to aging facilities (broken windows, faulty locks)
- Room smells, noise, renovation sounds bother guests - Unprofessional staff and poor reservation management

Recommended For

Solo travelers Business travelers Couples

Recommended For

Guest Reviews

Best Western Gregory Hotel

Expedia 10.0 Solo

Staff pleasant and helpful

Agoda 10.0 Couple

Staff, room, location all great

Agoda 9.6 Group

Near subway and shopping

Limited breakfast options

Trip.com 10.0 Business

Good location near subway

Booking.com 3.2 Couple

Great location, friendly staff, big room

No coffee

Sheridan Hotel

Agoda 3.2 Solo

Fire damage on microwave, torn window screens, and uncleaned room with hair in the bathtub.

Booking.com 2.0 Family

Room smelled like cigarettes, roach found under the bed, and insufficient towels.

Location Comparison

Distance: 25.9km

Best Western Gregory Hotel View Details → Sheridan Hotel View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.