Carnegie Hotel vs Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue Carnegie Hotel vs Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue
Same City · New York
Distance: 1.4km
Overview
vs
Carnegie Hotel
Carnegie Hotel
★★★★
4-Star
9.0
280 reviews
New York
Property Type: -
Room Size: -
Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue
Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue
★★★
3-Star
8.1
35 reviews
New York
Property Type: -
Room Size: -
Live Price Comparison
| Site | Carnegie Hotel Carnegie Hotel | Courtyard by Ma... Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue |
|---|---|---|
| Agoda | Checking | Checking |
| Booking.com | Checking | Checking |
| Expedia | Checking | Checking |
| Trip.com | Checking | Checking |
Rating Comparison by Booking Site
| Site | Carnegie Hotel Carnegie Hotel | Courtyard by Ma... Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue |
|---|---|---|
| Agoda |
8.9
(2,399)
|
8.2
(41)
|
| Booking.com |
8.8
(1,912)
|
7.7
(1,020)
|
| Expedia |
9.4
(1,004)
|
-
|
| Trip.com |
9.0
(117)
|
8.3
(129)
|
| Overall Average |
9.0
(5,432)
|
8.1
(1,190)
|
Strengths & Weaknesses
| Carnegie Hotel Carnegie Hotel | Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Strengths |
| + Prime spot by Carnegie Hall | + Prime spot near Bryant Park and Fifth Ave |
| + Friendly staff | + Clean and comfy rooms |
| + Spotless rooms | + Free coffee and water station |
| + Free breakfast & happy hour | + High family guest ratio |
| + High scores across sites | + Consistent low 8s scores |
| Weaknesses | Weaknesses |
| - Small rooms | - Small room sizes |
| - Facility fee | - Long waits for single elevator |
| - Thin walls | - No fridge or microwave |
Recommended For
Solo travelers
Families
Business travelers
Concert goers
|
Recommended For
Families
Business trips
Short stays
|
Guest Reviews
Carnegie Hotel
Carnegie Hotel
Booking sites
10.0
Solo
Small but clean room, super friendly staff. Breakfast omelet tasty, happy hour wine great.
Booking sites
10.0
Couple
Best location by Carnegie Hall & Central Park. Amazing staff.
Booking sites
4.0
Family
Great spot, friendly staff, wine hour & breakfast good.
Room a bit cramped
Booking sites
9.5
Family
Perfect location opposite Carnegie Hall. Nice breakfast & happy hour.
Room too small
Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue
Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Fifth Avenue
Booking sites
9.2
Family with teens
Location perfect, very close to Times Square. Not on busy street, easy access.
Booking sites
10
Family
Close to central station, easy to find on main street. Clean spacious room.
Booking sites
3.6
Nice staff, great location, coffee machine
Night street sounds
Booking sites
6.0
Group
Only one elevator working, long waits.
Location Comparison
Distance: 1.4km
This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.