New York Carnegie Hotel - Real Guest Reviews & Booking Info

  • ✓ Ratings from 4 booking sites
  • ✓ 4-Star Accommodation in New York
Live Price Compare In-depth Hotel Analysis Real Guest Reviews
New York Carnegie Hotel 4-Star Accommodation room
1 / 20
New York · Accommodation ·

Carnegie Hotel - New York 4-Star Accommodation

9.0/10
Expedia 9.4 · Agoda 9.0 · Trip.com 9.0 · Booking.com 8.8
Check-in 16:00 | Check-out 12:00

Hotel Analysis

Based on 4 sites · 5,432 reviews

Carnegie Hotel, a 4-star in New York, scores in the high 8s to 9s across booking sites. Solo travelers and families make up a big share. It's premium priced but reviewers see value in location and service. Reviews highlight the spot right by Carnegie Hall and near Central Park. Friendly staff, spotless rooms, free continental breakfast, and happy hour wine & snacks stand out. Elevators are quick with no waits. Rooms are compact with a facility fee gripe. Some noise issues from poor soundproofing, and happy hour space feels tight. Suits business trips or short concert stays.

Strengths

Prime spot by Carnegie Hall

Friendly staff

Spotless rooms

Free breakfast & happy hour

High scores across sites

Good to Know

Small rooms

Facility fee

Thin walls

Recommended For

Solo travelers — Handy location, compact setup

Families — Breakfast & happy hour family-friendly

Business travelers — Central Park & Midtown access

Concert goers — Next to Carnegie Hall

Check best prices for this hotel

Ratings by Booking Site

Overall 9.0/10 · 4 sites · Based on 5,432 reviews

Guest Reviews

4 booking sites · 5,432 reviews

Frequently Mentioned

Location Staff Cleanliness Breakfast Room size Facility fee
10.0 · booking sites · Solo
+ Small but clean room, super friendly staff. Breakfast omelet tasty, happy hour wine great.
10.0 · booking sites · Couple
+ Best location by Carnegie Hall & Central Park. Amazing staff.
4.0 · booking sites · Family
+ Great spot, friendly staff, wine hour & breakfast good.
- Room a bit cramped
9.5 · booking sites · Family
+ Perfect location opposite Carnegie Hall. Nice breakfast & happy hour.
- Room too small
See All 5,432 Reviews
Agoda 2,399 Booking.com 1,912 Expedia 1,004 Trip.com 117

Nearby

Google Maps

Loading map...

La Grande Boucherie

La Grande Boucherie

4.6 (9,992)
Restaurant 226m
Black Iron Burger Theater District | Hamburger restaurant Bar

Black Iron Burger Theater District | Hamburger restaurant Bar

4.7 (2,312)
Restaurant 292m
Le Bernardin

Le Bernardin

4.6 (4,552)
Restaurant 378m
Felice 56

Felice 56

4.6 (860)
Restaurant 439m
Duomo51

Duomo51

4.6 (1,534)
Restaurant 529m
EZ Paella & Tapas

EZ Paella & Tapas

4.8 (3,281)
Restaurant 730m
Margon

Margon

4.7 (1,451)
Restaurant 811m
Mitr Thai Restaurant

Mitr Thai Restaurant

4.9 (9,154)
Restaurant 857m
Benny John's Bar and Grill

Benny John's Bar and Grill

4.8 (2,491)
Restaurant 891m
Vegan On The Fly

Vegan On The Fly

4.7 (1,548)
Restaurant 982m
Canto Upper West Side

Canto Upper West Side

4.7 (902)
Restaurant 1.3km
72ND Eatery

72ND Eatery

4.7 (649)
Restaurant 1.4km
La Caridad 72

La Caridad 72

4.7 (461)
Restaurant 1.5km
Roma Pizza & restaurant

Roma Pizza & restaurant

4.7 (1,464)
Restaurant 1.6km
La Pecora Bianca UWS

La Pecora Bianca UWS

4.8 (2,958)
Restaurant 1.8km

New York Popular Tours & Activities

View all activities →

This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission.

FAQ

Typically, check-in starts at 3:00 PM and check-out is by 11:00 AM. Please contact the hotel directly for exact times.

Carnegie Hotel has received a rating of 9.0/10 from 280 guests.

Recommended Hotels in New York

전체 보기 →
$370 / night
Best Price