Hotel Analysis
Based on 4 sites · 5,432 reviews
Carnegie Hotel, a 4-star in New York, scores in the high 8s to 9s across booking sites. Solo travelers and families make up a big share. It's premium priced but reviewers see value in location and service. Reviews highlight the spot right by Carnegie Hall and near Central Park. Friendly staff, spotless rooms, free continental breakfast, and happy hour wine & snacks stand out. Elevators are quick with no waits. Rooms are compact with a facility fee gripe. Some noise issues from poor soundproofing, and happy hour space feels tight. Suits business trips or short concert stays.
Strengths
Prime spot by Carnegie Hall
Friendly staff
Spotless rooms
Free breakfast & happy hour
High scores across sites
Good to Know
Small rooms
Facility fee
Thin walls
Recommended For
Solo travelers — Handy location, compact setup
Families — Breakfast & happy hour family-friendly
Business travelers — Central Park & Midtown access
Concert goers — Next to Carnegie Hall
Ratings by Booking Site
Overall 9.0/10 · 4 sites · Based on 5,432 reviews
Guest Reviews
4 booking sites · 5,432 reviews
Frequently Mentioned
Nearby
Google MapsLoading map...
New York Popular Tours & Activities
View all activities →This post contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission.
FAQ
Typically, check-in starts at 3:00 PM and check-out is by 11:00 AM. Please contact the hotel directly for exact times.
Carnegie Hotel has received a rating of 9.0/10 from 280 guests.



















