Carnegie Hotel vs Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square

Same City · New York Distance: 1.3km
Change Hotel

Overview

vs

Carnegie Hotel

★★★★ 4-Star
9.0 280
New York
View Details →

Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square

★★★ 3-Star
8.0 44
New York
View Details →

Live Price Comparison

Site Carnegie Hotel Courtyard by Ma...
Agoda Checking Checking
Booking.com Checking Checking
Expedia Checking Checking
Trip.com Checking Checking

Rating Comparison by Booking Site

Site Carnegie Hotel Courtyard by Ma...
Agoda
8.9 (2,399)
8.4 (3,071)
Booking.com
8.8 (1,912)
8.1 (2,480)
Expedia
9.4 (1,004)
8.8 (1,176)
Trip.com
9.0 (117)
8.4 (123)
Overall Average
9.0 (5,432)
8.0 (6,850)

Strengths & Weaknesses

Carnegie Hotel Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square
Strengths Strengths
+ Prime spot by Carnegie Hall + Tons of reviews praise the location right by Times Square and subway for easy sightseeing and transit
+ Friendly staff + Staff friendliness and helpfulness repeated across sites
+ Spotless rooms + Comfy beds and quiet rooms despite city noise
+ Free breakfast & happy hour + Consistent mentions of good cleaning and clean rooms
+ High scores across sites
Weaknesses Weaknesses
- Small rooms - Some rooms have bathroom mold, no shower doors, or dirt issues
- Facility fee - Rooms feel small or dated, need updates
- Thin walls - AC, lights, or old TVs mentioned as broken

Recommended For

Solo travelers Families Business travelers Concert goers

Recommended For

Tourists Families Business travelers Solo travelers

Guest Reviews

Carnegie Hotel

Booking sites 10.0 Solo

Small but clean room, super friendly staff. Breakfast omelet tasty, happy hour wine great.

Booking sites 10.0 Couple

Best location by Carnegie Hall & Central Park. Amazing staff.

Booking sites 4.0 Family

Great spot, friendly staff, wine hour & breakfast good.

Room a bit cramped

Booking sites 9.5 Family

Perfect location opposite Carnegie Hall. Nice breakfast & happy hour.

Room too small

Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square

Expedia 10.0 Family

Great location, helpful staff, comfy bed, even airport taxi at 3AM

Expedia 10.0 Solo

Times Square 1min walk, subway corner, daily cleaning

Lost coffee cream

Agoda 9.2 Couple

Great location, clean Bryant Park nearby

Booking.com 10.0 Solo

Perfect location and bed, laundry access bonus

Expensive and bit dated

Trip.com 9.0 Family

Right by Times Square, decent breakfast

Location Comparison

Distance: 1.3km

Carnegie Hotel View Details → Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Times Square View Details →

This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.