NH Collection New York Madison Avenue vs The Shelburne Sonesta New York NH Collection New York Madison Avenue vs The Shelburne Sonesta New York
Same City · New York
Distance: 0.3km
Overview
vs
NH Collection New York Madison Avenue
NH Collection New York Madison Avenue
★★★★
4-Star
8.8
111 reviews
New York
Property Type: -
Room Size: -
The Shelburne Sonesta New York
The Shelburne Sonesta New York
★★★★
4-Star
8.1
287 reviews
New York
Property Type: -
Room Size: -
Live Price Comparison
| Site | NH Collection N... NH Collection New York Madison Avenue | The Shelburne S... The Shelburne Sonesta New York |
|---|---|---|
| Agoda | Checking | Checking |
| Booking.com | Checking | Checking |
| Expedia | Checking | Checking |
| Trip.com | Checking | Checking |
Rating Comparison by Booking Site
| Site | NH Collection N... NH Collection New York Madison Avenue | The Shelburne S... The Shelburne Sonesta New York |
|---|---|---|
| Agoda |
8.7
(1,855)
|
8.5
(3,239)
|
| Booking.com |
8.5
(1,558)
|
8.4
(2,392)
|
| Expedia |
8.8
(933)
|
9.0
(2,021)
|
| Trip.com |
8.9
(112)
|
8.6
(52)
|
| Overall Average |
8.8
(4,458)
|
8.1
(7,704)
|
Strengths & Weaknesses
| NH Collection New York Madison Avenue NH Collection New York Madison Avenue | The Shelburne Sonesta New York The Shelburne Sonesta New York |
|---|---|
| Strengths | Strengths |
| + Proximity to Grand Central makes sightseeing easy, repeated in reviews | + Convenient location for accessing major landmarks like Grand Central Terminal |
| + Rooms are clean with comfortable beds and good soundproofing | + Relatively quiet and peaceful rooms despite being in the heart of Manhattan |
| + Staff are friendly and helpful across reviews | + Friendly and responsive staff service |
| + Lobby bar with live music gets frequent praise | + Rooftop bar offering views of the New York skyline |
| + Fitness center with modern free equipment is convenient | |
| Weaknesses | Weaknesses |
| - Rooms are small by NYC standards, mentioned in several reviews | - Signs of aging due to the building's age, requiring maintenance |
| - Limited storage and coat hooks complained about | - Air conditioning noise and bathroom drainage issues in some rooms |
| - Occasional housekeeping issues or unfriendly staff noted | - Concerns regarding the cleanliness of carpets |
Recommended For
Couples
Business travelers
Solo travelers
Groups
|
Recommended For
Sightseers
Business Travelers
|
Guest Reviews
NH Collection New York Madison Avenue
NH Collection New York Madison Avenue
Expedia
10.0
Couple
Excellent location near Grand Central, clean beautiful room, friendly staff
Booking.com
8.5
Big rooms for NYC, great lounge bar with music, perfect value
Limited storage
Trip.com
10.0
Family
Friendly staff, clean room, great location
Agoda
10.0
Couple
Convenient location, clean quiet room, comfortable bed
Expedia
10.0
Spacious clean room, exceptional staff
The Shelburne Sonesta New York
The Shelburne Sonesta New York
Booking.com
8.0
Couple
Great location and super friendly staff. The room was quiet with a nice view.
Hot water could have been a touch hotter.
Expedia
10.0
Family
Staff are very accommodating and helpful. The room was clean and large.
Agoda
9.2
Family
Overall very clean and professional service. Location is very satisfying.
Bathroom layout is a bit inconvenient and facilities feel old.
Location Comparison
Distance: 0.3km
This page contains affiliate links and we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.